As a startup founder, one of the most nerve-wracking decisions you'll face is whether to exit early for a smaller payout or hold on for unicorn-level growth (valuing your company at over $1 billion).

It sounds glamorous to chase that unicorn status, but it comes with significant risks. The stakes can be incredibly high.

On one hand, an early exit can provide financial security and peace of mind, but you might wonder if you’re leaving potential billions on the table.

On the other hand, waiting for unicorn growth can lead to immense rewards, but if things don’t go as planned, you risk watching your dream crumble.

So, how do you decide?

Key Takeaways

1. Have an exit strategy from the start to stay flexible in case your market conditions change.

2. Keep a close eye on your financial runway to avoid running out of cash before achieving scale.

3. Analyze market trends to ensure you’re growing in a sustainable and profitable industry.

4. Align with your investors on risk appetite to ensure you're working towards shared goals.

5. Stay flexible and ready to pivot if scaling doesn't align with your long-term vision or financials.

Let’s start-up!

Earlier Exit v/s Unicorn Growth

A small exit isn’t pocket change, but compared to unicorn aspirations, it can feel small.

• Benefits of an Exit:

  1. Quick liquidity: You can cash out and secure your financial future.

  2. Lower risk: You get to avoid the stress of constantly fundraising and worrying about market changes.

  3. Founder satisfaction: Sometimes, the thrill of launching a business and getting to an exit is all you really want, and that’s a big win in itself.

On the flip side, there’s the chase for unicorn growth - growing your startup into a billion-dollar business. While it’s incredibly tempting, it’s also a marathon of risk and reward.

• Potential Rewards of Unicorn Growth:

  1. Larger valuation: Imagine turning your company into the next Uber or Airbnb. The financial returns could be astronomical.

  2. Bigger payout: When your valuation hits a billion dollars, even a small ownership stake could make you incredibly wealthy.

  3. Industry dominance: Achieving unicorn status often means you’re at the top of your market, with potential to reshape industries.

But with that kind of ambition comes significant risks:

• High burn rate: Many unicorn chasers burn through cash fast. You need constant funding, and if that dries up, it’s game over.

• Market volatility: Things outside of your control - market crashes, new competitors, or even global pandemics - can wipe out years of progress.

• Risk of bankruptcy: If things go sideways, you could lose everything you’ve built.

A classic example of unicorn-level ambition gone wrong is Quibi. It failed because it launched during the pandemic, but its short videos were meant for people on the go. It also didn’t offer content that stood out, leading to its rapid collapse just six months after launch.

On the other hand, Abhinay Choudhari, co-founder of Big Basket, silently left the company after TATA acquired a major stake because he wanted to “solve another equally painful chore for many Indian households” (Source).

In short, both options - exit or unicorn growth - come with their own sets of rewards and risks.

The key to making the right choice depends on factors like your financial runway, personal goals, and the market environment.

When to Consider Each Option:

Let’s look at some key areas where founders need to weigh their options.

1. Financial Burn Rate

29% of startups run out of cash before they can scale successfully.

Take Jumia, Africa’s first unicorn. The e-commerce company had massive potential and reached unicorn status, but it struggled to achieve profitability.

Jumia’s rapid growth required huge capital investments, and over time, the company burned through its cash reserves.

Eventually, its stock price dropped significantly, and it faced ongoing financial difficulties.

🔥Keep a close eye on your financial runway - the amount of time you have left before you run out of cash. If you're seeing your funding sources dry up and it’s getting harder to raise more money, it might be smarter to opt for a smaller exit before things get worse. You don’t want to be in a position where you're forced to sell at a loss or, worse, go bankrupt.

2. Market Trends and Timing

Even if your product is great, timing can be everything. According to CB Insights, 42% of startups fail because there’s no market need for their product. So, understanding market trends is vital.

for instance, Stayzilla, an Indian online accommodation service, aimed for large-scale growth but misjudged market demand and couldn’t control its burn rate. The company eventually had to shut down.

🔥Take the time to analyze both current and projected market trends. Is your market growing or shrinking? Are new competitors entering the space?

If it looks like the market is becoming saturated or unprofitable, an earlier exit might be the safer option. You don’t want to hold on too long and miss your chance to exit successfully.

3. Founder’s Goals

Not every founder is motivated purely by money or unicorn-level growth. For many, personal fulfillment is just as important.

For instance, Patreon was founded in 2013 and it grew slowly rather than chase unicorn status. Their goal was to empower creators, not just to reach a billion-dollar valuation. They’ve stayed true to this mission, focusing on sustainable growth and the long-term success of their users.

🔥 If you value personal fulfillment or have a specific mission in mind, chasing unicorn status might not be the best fit for you. For some founders, a smaller but successful business is far more rewarding than risking everything for a big payout that may never come.

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer when deciding between a small exit and chasing unicorn growth. Timing, industry trends, and strategic partnerships all play a key role in determining the best exit strategy for your startup.

The Exit vs. Growth Decision Framework:

While no one can predict the future, having a clear framework can help you make an informed choice.

Let’s break down a simple decision-making process based on two key factors: product-market fit and risk appetite.

Assess Product-Market Fit:

Before making any decisions about exiting or growing, the first thing you need to evaluate is your product-market fit.

Simply put, product-market fit refers to how well your product solves a problem for your target audience.

If your product is gaining traction, with strong demand and satisfied customers, you may have an opportunity to scale.

On the other hand, if the fit is weak or the market is still unsure, pushing for unicorn-level growth can be extremely risky.

You could end up burning through cash trying to make the product work, only to discover that the market doesn’t truly need what you're offering.

🔥Recognize that without strong product-market fit, scaling too fast can lead to failure.

Risk Appetite:

The second key factor to consider is risk appetite - both yours and that of your investors.

Some founders and investors are comfortable taking big risks for the possibility of massive rewards.

Others are more conservative, preferring stable, smaller returns over uncertainty.

Ultimately, your risk tolerance will guide your exit strategy.

However, keep in mind that even with high risk tolerance, the market may not always cooperate, and the stakes are high if the growth doesn’t come as expected.

🔥 It’s important to align with your investors on risk. But it’s crucial to know when to cut your losses.

Create a Decision Matrix

To simplify the process, you can create a decision matrix to quantify which path - small exit or continued growth - aligns better with your startup’s future. Here’s how you can build one:

1. Product Viability:
   Is your product scalable, and is there a strong demand?

2. Cash Flow:
   How healthy are your financials? Are you burning through cash quickly, or do you have a long runway?

3. Market Trends:
   Is your market growing, shrinking, or becoming saturated? A growing market suggests potential for continued growth, while a shrinking market may point towards a quicker exit.

4. Personal Goals:
   Do you want to grow a massive company, or are you content with a smaller, successful business? What about your investors?

If you score high across these areas, pushing for unicorn growth may be worth the risk.

If your scores are lower or you’re unsure, an exit might be the more strategic move.

This framework will help you think through your options systematically rather than relying on gut feelings or external pressure.

Final Insights:

Every start-up founder faces unique challenges, and the best decision will depend on your circumstances. Below are some actionable insights to help guide you through this tricky decision-making process.

1. Have an Exit Strategy from Day One

It’s easy to get caught up in daydreams about massive success, but it’s essential to have an exit strategy from the start.

Even if you're aiming for unicorn-level growth, knowing when and how you'd exit can save you from making rushed, last-minute decisions if things don’t go as planned.

Having an exit strategy in place gives you flexibility - whether it’s aiming for a smaller acquisition, planning an IPO, or preparing to scale.

That way, if market conditions change or your startup's growth plateaus, you'll have a fallback plan ready to go.

2. Consult Your Investors Early:

Your investors are your partners, not just financially but also strategically.

Keeping them in the loop about your plans to scale or exit is essential.

Not only can they offer guidance based on their experience, but they often have a significant influence on what happens next.

It’s important to align your goals with theirs to avoid conflicts when critical decisions arise.

3. Build Flexibility into Your Plan

As your company grows, you’ll need to keep an eye on key metrics like your burn rate, product-market fit, and customer acquisition costs.

These numbers should guide your decision-making and indicate whether it’s time to adjust your approach.

For instance, if your burn rate is unsustainable or customer acquisition costs are skyrocketing, it might signal that scaling further could put you in danger.

On the other hand, if the numbers are trending positively, you may be in a strong position to aim for larger growth.

Continuously revisit your business plan as your company evolves. By staying flexible and adjusting based on real-time data, you'll be better equipped to decide whether to keep scaling or consider an earlier exit.

4. Don’t Be Afraid to Pivot or Exit Early

Many founders set their sights on unicorn status, thinking anything less is a failure. But that's far from the truth.

Sometimes, the market conditions or business environment aren’t favorable, and pivoting or exiting early can be the smarter, more strategic move.

Don’t let pride or external pressures force you into chasing unicorn growth if the data or market isn't aligned.

A small exit is often better than pushing your company to the brink of failure.

5. Continuously Re-Evaluate Your Strategy

As you grow, always take a step back to re-evaluate your approach.

The conditions that were present when you launched your startup will evolve, and so should your strategy.

Factors like market shifts, competitor actions, and internal growth will affect whether you should scale up or exit early.

If you find that scaling doesn’t align with your financials or long-term vision, don’t hesitate to pivot or consider an exit.

Flexibility and adaptability are the keys to long-term success.

Final Thoughts:

At the end of the day, there’s no single right answer to the question of whether you should exit early or aim for unicorn growth.

Each founder’s journey is different, and the best move for one company might not work for another.

What’s important is that you remain thoughtful and strategic throughout the process.

Continuously check in with yourself and your business to ensure you’re on the right path, and don’t be afraid to change course when necessary.

Whether you exit early or chase unicorn status, being informed and adaptable will put you in the best position to succeed.

Thank you for participating in the poll, it helps us create better content for you!